EP #35
He Wants to Propose. His Girlfriend Wants to Leave.
Show Notes
How much trouble can one tiny piece of jewelry cause? Apparently quite a lot.
A woman finds herself holding a secret that no one wants to be responsible for: her best friend is excitedly preparing to propose, while his girlfriend has privately admitted that she's not even sure she wants to stay in the relationship. Now she's being asked to help pick out the ring while knowing it might be headed straight toward heartbreak. Does being a good friend mean speaking up, keeping a confidence, or finding some impossible third option that doesn't betray anyone?
Then, a woman who has spent years trying to keep an ex firmly in the past receives a very unexpected Christmas gift in the mail: a ring. He has a girlfriend. She has a partner. She has also blocked him basically everywhere humanly possible, which apparently hasn’t stopped the postal service from becoming an unwilling participant in his romantic nostalgia. Does she warn his current girlfriend, or would that just drag her back into drama she worked very hard to escape?
Two rings, two messy relationships, and one recurring problem: sometimes knowing too much makes staying out of it a lot harder.
CONTENT NOTE
This episode includes discussions of relationship conflict, depression and suicidal ideation, financial distress, dishonesty, infidelity, and unwanted contact from a former partner.
STORY ONE
My best friend is about to propose, but his girlfriend just told me she's thinking of breaking up. What do I do?
Being caught between two friends is awkward. Being caught between them while one is shopping for an engagement ring and the other is privately considering a breakup is the sort of logistical nightmare that friendship does not adequately prepare you for.
Benny is ready to propose to his girlfriend of three years, Annie, despite a relationship marked by distance, little intimacy, and an apparent allergy to difficult conversations. Meanwhile, Annie has confided in their mutual best friend that she loves Benny but isn't sure he's "the one." Then Benny asks that same friend to help him choose the ring. Excellent timing all around.
Now, the OP is carrying information that could change everything, along with the knowledge that Benny is already emotionally vulnerable. The real dilemma sits somewhere between confidentiality and loyalty: when two people keep telling a mutual friend what they should be telling each other, staying neutral becomes its own kind of involvement.
STORY SOURCES
STORY TWO
WIBTA if I told my ex's girlfriend that he sent me a ring for Christmas?
Three years after a breakup, most people have settled comfortably into the "please remain in my past" phase of the relationship. Unfortunately, one woman's ex has declined to participate.
After their relationship ended over his cheating, she blocked him on her personal phone, work phone, and social media. He kept finding other ways to make contact anyway. Then Christmas arrives, and so does a package containing a ring—which feels less festive when it comes from an ex who currently lives several states away with the woman he cheated with.
Now the OP is considering telling his girlfriend about the ongoing messages and gifts. She has proof, a current partner of her own, and very little interest in rekindling anything. What she does have is an increasingly persistent boundary problem and the uncomfortable decision of whether exposing his behavior would finally end it or simply reopen a door she has spent years trying to close.
STORY SOURCES
Support the Show
Love listening to us unpack strangers’ highly questionable decisions? Help us keep the microphones on, the coffee fresh, and the Reddit tabs open.
Your support directly helps cover hosting fees, production equipment, and the emotional cost of reading Reddit.
LISTEN ON
Show Notes
Show Notes
How much trouble can one tiny piece of jewelry cause? Apparently quite a lot.
A woman finds herself holding a secret that no one wants to be responsible for: her best friend is excitedly preparing to propose, while his girlfriend has privately admitted that she's not even sure she wants to stay in the relationship. Now she's being asked to help pick out the ring while knowing it might be headed straight toward heartbreak. Does being a good friend mean speaking up, keeping a confidence, or finding some impossible third option that doesn't betray anyone?
Then, a woman who has spent years trying to keep an ex firmly in the past receives a very unexpected Christmas gift in the mail: a ring. He has a girlfriend. She has a partner. She has also blocked him basically everywhere humanly possible, which apparently hasn’t stopped the postal service from becoming an unwilling participant in his romantic nostalgia. Does she warn his current girlfriend, or would that just drag her back into drama she worked very hard to escape?
Two rings, two messy relationships, and one recurring problem: sometimes knowing too much makes staying out of it a lot harder.
CONTENT NOTE
CONTENT NOTE
This episode includes discussions of relationship conflict, breach of trust, emotional manipulation, and family estrangement.
This episode includes discussions of relationship conflict, breach of trust, emotional manipulation, and family estrangement.
EP #35
He Wants to Propose. His Girlfriend Wants to Leave.
Photo: Midjourney
Show Notes
Show Notes
In this episode, we dive into a collection of Reddit stories about the secrets people keep, the questionable decisions they make, and what happens when the truth finally finds its way into the group chat. Spoiler: it never ends well.
How much trouble can one tiny piece of jewelry cause? Apparently quite a lot.
A woman finds herself holding a secret that no one wants to be responsible for: her best friend is excitedly preparing to propose, while his girlfriend has privately admitted that she's not even sure she wants to stay in the relationship. Now she's being asked to help pick out the ring while knowing it might be headed straight toward heartbreak. Does being a good friend mean speaking up, keeping a confidence, or finding some impossible third option that doesn't betray anyone?
Then, a woman who has spent years trying to keep an ex firmly in the past receives a very unexpected Christmas gift in the mail: a ring. He has a girlfriend. She has a partner. She has also blocked him basically everywhere humanly possible, which apparently hasn’t stopped the postal service from becoming an unwilling participant in his romantic nostalgia. Does she warn his current girlfriend, or would that just drag her back into drama she worked very hard to escape?
Two rings, two messy relationships, and one recurring problem: sometimes knowing too much makes staying out of it a lot harder.
CONTENT NOTE
This episode includes discussions of relationship conflict, breach of trust, emotional manipulation, and family estrangement.
STORY ONE
My best friend is about to propose, but his girlfriend just told me she's thinking of breaking up. What do I do?
My best friend is about to propose, but his girlfriend just told me she's thinking of breaking up. What do I do?
Being caught between two friends is awkward. Being caught between them while one is shopping for an engagement ring and the other is privately considering a breakup is the sort of logistical nightmare that friendship does not adequately prepare you for.
Benny is ready to propose to his girlfriend of three years, Annie, despite a relationship marked by distance, little intimacy, and an apparent allergy to difficult conversations. Meanwhile, Annie has confided in their mutual best friend that she loves Benny but isn't sure he's "the one." Then Benny asks that same friend to help him choose the ring. Excellent timing all around.
Now, the OP is carrying information that could change everything, along with the knowledge that Benny is already emotionally vulnerable. The real dilemma sits somewhere between confidentiality and loyalty: when two people keep telling a mutual friend what they should be telling each other, staying neutral becomes its own kind of involvement.
STORY TWO
The Wedding Group Chat
WIBTA if I told my ex's girlfriend that he sent me a ring for Christmas?
Three years after a breakup, most people have settled comfortably into the "please remain in my past" phase of the relationship. Unfortunately, one woman's ex has declined to participate.
After their relationship ended over his cheating, she blocked him on her personal phone, work phone, and social media. He kept finding other ways to make contact anyway. Then Christmas arrives, and so does a package containing a ring—which feels less festive when it comes from an ex who currently lives several states away with the woman he cheated with.
Now the OP is considering telling his girlfriend about the ongoing messages and gifts. She has proof, a current partner of her own, and very little interest in rekindling anything. What she does have is an increasingly persistent boundary problem and the uncomfortable decision of whether exposing his behavior would finally end it or simply reopen a door she has spent years trying to close.
Support the Show
Love listening to us unpack strangers’ highly questionable decisions? Help us keep the microphones on, the coffee fresh, and the Reddit tabs open.
Your support directly helps cover hosting fees, production equipment, and the emotional cost of reading Reddit.
Two best friends. One internet. Too many confessions. Unpacking messy Reddit threads and dramatic stories every other Wednesday.
LISTEN & FOLLOW
© 2026 Secondhand Confessions. All rights reserved.
Everybody has a story.
Support the Show
Love listening to us unpack strangers’ highly questionable decisions? Help us keep the microphones on, the coffee fresh, and the Reddit tabs open.
Your support directly helps cover hosting fees, production equipment, and the emotional cost of reading Reddit.
EP #35
He Wants to Propose. His Girlfriend Wants to Leave.
STORY ONE
My best friend is about to propose, but his girlfriend just told me she's thinking of breaking up. What do I do?
Being caught between two friends is awkward. Being caught between them while one is shopping for an engagement ring and the other is privately considering a breakup is the sort of logistical nightmare that friendship does not adequately prepare you for.
Benny is ready to propose to his girlfriend of three years, Annie, despite a relationship marked by distance, little intimacy, and an apparent allergy to difficult conversations. Meanwhile, Annie has confided in their mutual best friend that she loves Benny but isn't sure he's "the one." Then Benny asks that same friend to help him choose the ring. Excellent timing all around.
Now, the OP is carrying information that could change everything, along with the knowledge that Benny is already emotionally vulnerable. The real dilemma sits somewhere between confidentiality and loyalty: when two people keep telling a mutual friend what they should be telling each other, staying neutral becomes its own kind of involvement.
STORY TWO
WIBTA if I told my ex's girlfriend that he sent me a ring for Christmas?
WIBTA if I told my ex's girlfriend that he sent me a ring for Christmas?
Three years after a breakup, most people have settled comfortably into the "please remain in my past" phase of the relationship. Unfortunately, one woman's ex has declined to participate.
After their relationship ended over his cheating, she blocked him on her personal phone, work phone, and social media. He kept finding other ways to make contact anyway. Then Christmas arrives, and so does a package containing a ring—which feels less festive when it comes from an ex who currently lives several states away with the woman he cheated with.
Now the OP is considering telling his girlfriend about the ongoing messages and gifts. She has proof, a current partner of her own, and very little interest in rekindling anything. What she does have is an increasingly persistent boundary problem and the uncomfortable decision of whether exposing his behavior would finally end it or simply reopen a door she has spent years trying to close.