EP #36
My Boyfriend Put Benadryl In My Drink
Show Notes
Some relationship disagreements end with an awkward car ride and aggressive control of the aux cord. Others apparently end with one person deciding pharmaceutical intervention is easier than conflict resolution. After arguing with her boyfriend before an eight-hour road trip, one woman sleeps through nearly the entire drive—only to learn that her sudden exhaustion wasn’t exactly spontaneous. His explanation brings a much larger pattern of control into focus, including tension over her wanting to stay with her mother, return to work, and maintain some basic independence. Turns out “I just wanted some peace and quiet” has limits.
Then, family obligation gets unusually anatomical. A man spent years distancing himself from his family after his sister knowingly built a life with the high-school bully who targeted him relentlessly after he was outed. Now his sister is seriously ill and needs a kidney transplant. With other relatives unable to donate, the family turns to her estranged brother as a potential match. It’s an enormous request layered over years of hurt, dismissal, and fractured relationships—and a reminder that sharing DNA can create expectations, but it doesn’t make questions of bodily autonomy any less complicated.
Two stories about people discovering just how much access partners and relatives believe they’re entitled to have: to your choices, your independence, and, apparently, your internal organs.
CONTENT NOTE
This episode includes discussions of abusive relationships, coercive control, non-consensual drugging, emotional and financial abuse, homophobic bullying and slurs, family estrangement, serious illness, and organ donation.
STORY ONE
My boyfriend (35M) drugged me (26F) with Benadryl because we got into an argument before our road trip and he wanted me to sleep the whole time
An 8-hour road trip after an argument is already a fairly ambitious relationship exercise. After disagreeing with her boyfriend about wanting to spend some time at her mom's house, one woman gets in the car, drinks what he gives her, and unexpectedly sleeps through nearly the entire drive. Later, her boyfriend casually admits that her unusually successful nap had some pharmaceutical assistance: he secretly put Benadryl in her drink because he didn’t want to deal with her arguing.
The admission becomes even more unsettling against a larger pattern involving her job, finances, living situation, and attempts to spend time away from him. What initially sounds like one profoundly inappropriate solution to an inconvenient disagreement starts raising much bigger issues around trust, coercive control, bodily autonomy, and the difference between supporting a partner and quietly making their choices for them.
STORY SOURCES
STORY TWO
AITAH for refusing to donate my kidney to my dying sister because she got with my high school bully?
Family obligation gets considerably more complicated when the favor involves an internal organ. Years after his sister began dating—and eventually married—the high-school bully who relentlessly targeted him after he was outed, a man has largely distanced himself from his family. Then his sister becomes seriously ill and needs a kidney transplant. With other relatives unable to donate, the family turns to her estranged brother as a potential match.
Suddenly, years of bullying, dismissal, and fractured family relationships are sharing space with an urgent medical crisis and a request that goes several steps beyond helping someone move apartments. Beneath the kidney dilemma is a thornier conflict about bodily autonomy, forgiveness, and family loyalty—and how much obligation remains when the people invoking “family” previously treated your pain as something you should simply get over.
STORY SOURCES
Support the Show
Love listening to us unpack strangers’ highly questionable decisions? Help us keep the microphones on, the coffee fresh, and the Reddit tabs open.
Your support directly helps cover hosting fees, production equipment, and the emotional cost of reading Reddit.
LISTEN ON
Show Notes
Show Notes
Some relationship disagreements end with an awkward car ride and aggressive control of the aux cord. Others apparently end with one person deciding pharmaceutical intervention is easier than conflict resolution. After arguing with her boyfriend before an eight-hour road trip, one woman sleeps through nearly the entire drive—only to learn that her sudden exhaustion wasn’t exactly spontaneous. His explanation brings a much larger pattern of control into focus, including tension over her wanting to stay with her mother, return to work, and maintain some basic independence. Turns out “I just wanted some peace and quiet” has limits.
Then, family obligation gets unusually anatomical. A man spent years distancing himself from his family after his sister knowingly built a life with the high-school bully who targeted him relentlessly after he was outed. Now his sister is seriously ill and needs a kidney transplant. With other relatives unable to donate, the family turns to her estranged brother as a potential match. It’s an enormous request layered over years of hurt, dismissal, and fractured relationships—and a reminder that sharing DNA can create expectations, but it doesn’t make questions of bodily autonomy any less complicated.
Two stories about people discovering just how much access partners and relatives believe they’re entitled to have: to your choices, your independence, and, apparently, your internal organs.
CONTENT NOTE
CONTENT NOTE
This episode includes discussions of relationship conflict, breach of trust, emotional manipulation, and family estrangement.
This episode includes discussions of relationship conflict, breach of trust, emotional manipulation, and family estrangement.
EP #36
My Boyfriend Put Benadryl In My Drink
Photo: Midjourney
Show Notes
Show Notes
In this episode, we dive into a collection of Reddit stories about the secrets people keep, the questionable decisions they make, and what happens when the truth finally finds its way into the group chat. Spoiler: it never ends well.
Some relationship disagreements end with an awkward car ride and aggressive control of the aux cord. Others apparently end with one person deciding pharmaceutical intervention is easier than conflict resolution. After arguing with her boyfriend before an eight-hour road trip, one woman sleeps through nearly the entire drive—only to learn that her sudden exhaustion wasn’t exactly spontaneous. His explanation brings a much larger pattern of control into focus, including tension over her wanting to stay with her mother, return to work, and maintain some basic independence. Turns out “I just wanted some peace and quiet” has limits.
Then, family obligation gets unusually anatomical. A man spent years distancing himself from his family after his sister knowingly built a life with the high-school bully who targeted him relentlessly after he was outed. Now his sister is seriously ill and needs a kidney transplant. With other relatives unable to donate, the family turns to her estranged brother as a potential match. It’s an enormous request layered over years of hurt, dismissal, and fractured relationships—and a reminder that sharing DNA can create expectations, but it doesn’t make questions of bodily autonomy any less complicated.
Two stories about people discovering just how much access partners and relatives believe they’re entitled to have: to your choices, your independence, and, apparently, your internal organs.
CONTENT NOTE
This episode includes discussions of relationship conflict, breach of trust, emotional manipulation, and family estrangement.
STORY ONE
My boyfriend (35M) drugged me (26F) with Benadryl because we got into an argument before our road trip and he wanted me to sleep the whole time
My boyfriend (35M) drugged me (26F) with Benadryl because we got into an argument before our road trip and he wanted me to sleep the whole time
An 8-hour road trip after an argument is already a fairly ambitious relationship exercise. After disagreeing with her boyfriend about wanting to spend some time at her mom's house, one woman gets in the car, drinks what he gives her, and unexpectedly sleeps through nearly the entire drive. Later, her boyfriend casually admits that her unusually successful nap had some pharmaceutical assistance: he secretly put Benadryl in her drink because he didn’t want to deal with her arguing.
The admission becomes even more unsettling against a larger pattern involving her job, finances, living situation, and attempts to spend time away from him. What initially sounds like one profoundly inappropriate solution to an inconvenient disagreement starts raising much bigger issues around trust, coercive control, bodily autonomy, and the difference between supporting a partner and quietly making their choices for them.
STORY TWO
The Wedding Group Chat
AITAH for refusing to donate my kidney to my dying sister because she got with my high school bully?
Family obligation gets considerably more complicated when the favor involves an internal organ. Years after his sister began dating—and eventually married—the high-school bully who relentlessly targeted him after he was outed, a man has largely distanced himself from his family. Then his sister becomes seriously ill and needs a kidney transplant. With other relatives unable to donate, the family turns to her estranged brother as a potential match.
Suddenly, years of bullying, dismissal, and fractured family relationships are sharing space with an urgent medical crisis and a request that goes several steps beyond helping someone move apartments. Beneath the kidney dilemma is a thornier conflict about bodily autonomy, forgiveness, and family loyalty—and how much obligation remains when the people invoking “family” previously treated your pain as something you should simply get over.
Support the Show
Love listening to us unpack strangers’ highly questionable decisions? Help us keep the microphones on, the coffee fresh, and the Reddit tabs open.
Your support directly helps cover hosting fees, production equipment, and the emotional cost of reading Reddit.
Two best friends. One internet. Too many confessions. Unpacking messy Reddit threads and dramatic stories every other Wednesday.
LISTEN & FOLLOW
© 2026 Secondhand Confessions. All rights reserved.
Everybody has a story.
Support the Show
Love listening to us unpack strangers’ highly questionable decisions? Help us keep the microphones on, the coffee fresh, and the Reddit tabs open.
Your support directly helps cover hosting fees, production equipment, and the emotional cost of reading Reddit.
EP #36
My Boyfriend Put Benadryl In My Drink
STORY ONE
My boyfriend (35M) drugged me (26F) with Benadryl because we got into an argument before our road trip and he wanted me to sleep the whole time
An 8-hour road trip after an argument is already a fairly ambitious relationship exercise. After disagreeing with her boyfriend about wanting to spend some time at her mom's house, one woman gets in the car, drinks what he gives her, and unexpectedly sleeps through nearly the entire drive. Later, her boyfriend casually admits that her unusually successful nap had some pharmaceutical assistance: he secretly put Benadryl in her drink because he didn’t want to deal with her arguing.
The admission becomes even more unsettling against a larger pattern involving her job, finances, living situation, and attempts to spend time away from him. What initially sounds like one profoundly inappropriate solution to an inconvenient disagreement starts raising much bigger issues around trust, coercive control, bodily autonomy, and the difference between supporting a partner and quietly making their choices for them.
STORY TWO
AITAH for refusing to donate my kidney to my dying sister because she got with my high school bully?
AITAH for refusing to donate my kidney to my dying sister because she got with my high school bully?
Family obligation gets considerably more complicated when the favor involves an internal organ. Years after his sister began dating—and eventually married—the high-school bully who relentlessly targeted him after he was outed, a man has largely distanced himself from his family. Then his sister becomes seriously ill and needs a kidney transplant. With other relatives unable to donate, the family turns to her estranged brother as a potential match.
Suddenly, years of bullying, dismissal, and fractured family relationships are sharing space with an urgent medical crisis and a request that goes several steps beyond helping someone move apartments. Beneath the kidney dilemma is a thornier conflict about bodily autonomy, forgiveness, and family loyalty—and how much obligation remains when the people invoking “family” previously treated your pain as something you should simply get over.